sad

Chapter 4: The Woman Who Knew Too Much

“Because you're making this bigger than it needs to be!””

Brielle's voice cracked across the kitchen, loud enough to reach the guests gathered in the living room.

Marcus didn't lower his phone.

“Then give me one good reason not to call the bank.””

Brielle stared at him, her emerald-green dress dripping dirty water onto the pristine white floor. Her carefully styled hair remained perfect, but her face had lost every trace of the confidence she'd worn when she ordered Loretta to wash dishes.

“Because your mother is confused,” Brielle snapped.

“She gave me permission to use her card, and now she's changing her story because you decided to embarrass me.””

Loretta slowly shook her head.

“I haven't changed anything, Brielle.””

“Then explain why you let me use it!””

“I already did. You said you needed groceries.””

“And I bought groceries!””

“Not a twenty-thousand-dollar dress.””

Brielle threw her hands into the air.

“Unbelievable!””

Marcus moved closer to his mother.

“Mom, sit down for a minute.””

“I'm all right, sweetheart.””

“No, you're not.””

He pulled a chair away from the kitchen island and placed it beside her. Loretta sat reluctantly, smoothing her damp cardigan over her knees. Her hands trembled as she clasped them together.

Marcus noticed the raw skin around her knuckles.

He had seen those hands work for decades. They had packed his school lunches, held his forehead when he was sick, and gripped his shoulder on the day he graduated from college.

Now they were trembling because his fiancée had humiliated her in front of an entire room of people.

He turned back to Brielle.

“Give me the card.””

“What card?””

“My mother's card.””

“I don't have it!””

“Then where is it?””

“I told you, I returned it!””

Loretta lifted her head.

“No, Brielle. You gave me a different card. I checked the number when I got home.””

The silence that followed was immediate.

Marcus stared at his fiancée.

“You checked the number?””

Loretta nodded.

“I was looking for my insurance card. I found the one Brielle returned in the pocket of my purse. It wasn't mine.””

“Why didn't you tell me?””

Her eyes filled.

“Because I didn't want to start trouble between you two. You were so happy about the wedding.””

Marcus swallowed hard.

“And you thought you had to handle this alone?””

Loretta looked at him with the exhausted expression of a woman who had spent her life making other people's problems smaller.

“I thought perhaps there was an explanation.””

Brielle scoffed.

“There is an explanation. Your mother is making assumptions.””

A man near the kitchen entrance cleared his throat.

It was Uncle Raymond, Marcus's mother's younger brother. He had arrived an hour earlier with his wife and had spent most of the party chatting with relatives.

“Brielle,” he said, “I watched your mother-in-law-to-be wash dishes while you stood there showing off that dress. Whatever happened with the card, you owe Loretta an apology.””

Brielle whipped around.

“Excuse me? This is between Marcus and me.””

“You made it everybody's business when you ordered his mother around in front of thirty people.””

Several guests nodded.

Brielle's cheeks burned.

“You all have no idea what it's like being expected to marry into this family!””

Marcus stared at her.

“Expected?””

“Yes! Everything has to be perfect for your mother. Every dinner, every holiday, every stupid family gathering. I can't breathe without someone telling me what Loretta prefers.””

Loretta looked stunned.

“I have never asked you to do anything for me.””

“You don't have to ask!”” Brielle shouted.

“Everyone expects me to do it!””

“Do what?”” Marcus demanded.

“Be the perfect daughter-in-law!””

Marcus glanced at the sink overflowing with dishes.

“Is that what you call this?””

Brielle followed his gaze.

For a moment, she looked almost embarrassed.

Then her expression hardened again.

“You're choosing her over me.””

“I'm choosing not to let you humiliate her.””

“So that's it? One receipt, one misunderstanding, and you're ready to throw away our future?””

“No,” Marcus said.

“I'm asking you to explain why my mother's name is on a receipt for a dress you claim you bought yourself.””

Brielle opened her mouth.

Before she could answer, a woman in a champagne-colored suit stepped forward from the living room.

Vanessa.

She had been Brielle's closest friend since college. She was also the person who had accompanied Brielle on several shopping trips in recent months.

“Marcus,” Vanessa said, looking uncomfortable, “there's something you should know.””

Brielle spun around.

“Vanessa, don't.””

Vanessa hesitated.

Marcus lowered his phone slightly.

“What is it?””

Vanessa looked at Loretta, then at the soaked dress.

“I was with Brielle when she bought it.””

Brielle's face went rigid.

“And?”” Marcus asked.

Vanessa swallowed.

“She didn't pay with her own card.””

Brielle lunged toward her.

“Shut your mouth!””

Vanessa stepped back, nearly colliding with a guest carrying a glass of water.

Marcus caught Brielle by the arm before she could move closer.

“Don't touch her.””

“Let go of me!”” Brielle shouted.

He released her immediately.

Vanessa's voice trembled, but she continued.

“The saleswoman asked for identification because the purchase was so expensive. Brielle handed over a card and said it belonged to someone in the family.””

Marcus felt his stomach tighten.

“Whose family?””

Vanessa looked directly at Loretta.

“She said it was her future mother-in-law's card.””

Loretta brought a hand to her mouth.

Marcus stared at Brielle.

“You told people you had permission.””

Brielle looked around at the guests, searching for someone willing to defend her.

Nobody spoke.

Then Vanessa reached into her handbag.

“I have something else.””

She pulled out her phone, opened a photograph, and turned the screen toward Marcus.

It showed Brielle standing in front of a boutique mirror, smiling in the same emerald dress.

But that wasn't what caught his attention.

On the counter beside her lay a black bank card.

Marcus recognized the name printed on it.

Loretta Carter.

He looked up.

“Vanessa, when was this picture taken?””

Vanessa's lips parted.

“Three weeks ago.””

Marcus's heart began pounding.

Three weeks ago, his mother had been visiting her sister in Ohio.

May you like

She had never even been in that boutique.

And Vanessa was about to tell him exactly what Brielle had said when the saleswoman asked whose card she was holding.

Related Stories

Other posts