Chapter 3: The Second Recording

Vanessa's scream carried through the doorway and into the reception hall.

Marcus caught her wrist before she could reach the phone. He released it immediately, stepping back with Lily's warning still echoing in his mind.

“Don't touch me,” Vanessa snapped.

“Then stop trying to take my daughter's property.””

“I am your fiancée!””

“Not an answer.””

Vanessa stared at him, breathing hard. Her wedding veil had slipped crookedly across one shoulder, and a loose strand of hair clung to her cheek.

Beyond the curtain, the music continued.

Andre remained in the doorway with Lily beside him.

“Marcus,” Andre said carefully, “do you want me to call security?””

“Yes.””

“No!”” Vanessa shouted.

Andre's eyebrows rose.

Marcus looked directly at her.

“Why not?””

Vanessa swallowed.

“Because this is a private family matter.””

“You put a cloth over my daughter's mouth. You lied about knowing my wife. And now you're terrified of a recording.””

“I am terrified of losing everything I've worked for!””

The confession escaped before she could stop it.

Marcus stared at her.

“What exactly have you worked for, Vanessa?””

She looked at the floor.

He waited.

She offered nothing.

Lily moved closer to Andre, rubbing her damp cheeks against the shoulder of her little pink dress.

Marcus turned back to the phone.

“I'm listening to the message.””

Vanessa shook her head frantically.

“Marcus, please. You don't understand what you're about to hear.””

“Then explain it.””

“I can't.””

“Can't or won't?””

Her eyes filled with tears, but Marcus no longer knew whether they were real.

“You promised you'd trust me,” she whispered.

“I trusted you with my daughter.””

Vanessa looked at Lily.

The little girl immediately turned away.

Marcus pressed play.

A soft burst of static filled the space behind the curtain.

Then Renee's voice emerged.

“Marcus, if you're hearing this, I need you to understand something. I didn't keep secrets because I stopped loving you.””

Marcus's knees weakened.

He sat on a nearby chair without taking his eyes off the screen.

Renee sounded tired. Not frightened exactly, but careful, as if she were choosing each word with someone listening nearby.

“I wanted to tell you everything,” the recording continued.

“I tried more than once. But every time I thought I was ready, I realized that if I was wrong, I could destroy our family for nothing.””

Marcus closed his eyes.

He remembered Renee sitting at their kitchen table late one evening, a cup of tea untouched between her hands.

If someone you loved turned out to be different from who you thought they were, would you want to know?

He had smiled and told her that everyone had flaws.

She hadn't smiled back.

At the time, he'd been checking messages from work.

He had promised to discuss it later.

Later never came.

“Renee,” he whispered.

Vanessa stood against the curtain, watching the phone as if it were a loaded weapon.

The recording continued.

“I know you're going to ask why I didn't come straight to you. I know you'll think I should have trusted you enough to explain.””

Marcus opened his eyes.

“But I needed proof,” Renee said.

“And I needed to know that Lily would be safe if I was no longer there to protect her.””

Marcus looked toward his daughter.

Lily was listening now, her small face pale beneath the bright daylight.

“Mommy,” she whispered.

The recording crackled.

“There's something you need to find. It's connected to the day we met Vanessa.””

Marcus's head lifted.

The day they met Vanessa.

He remembered it clearly: a charity fundraiser at a downtown hotel, nearly three years earlier. Vanessa had approached Renee while Marcus was speaking with a business associate. The two women had exchanged a long look, then moved toward a quiet corner.

When he asked what they'd discussed, Renee had said they knew someone in common.

He'd forgotten about it.

Or perhaps he'd never understood it mattered.

“What day?”” Marcus asked the phone, though he knew the recording couldn't answer him.

Renee's voice lowered.

“Look inside the blue envelope I left with the things I told you not to throw away. You'll know it when you see it.””

Marcus felt a sharp pang of recognition.

After Renee's death, he'd packed her personal belongings into labeled boxes. He remembered one blue envelope, sealed and tucked between the pages of a notebook.

He had found it months later while cleaning the closet.

Vanessa had been with him.

She had asked what was inside.

He'd told her he didn't know.

She'd said he should throw it away if it only brought back painful memories.

And he had almost done exactly that.

The recording continued.

“If the envelope is missing, don't confront her until you understand why. Please, Marcus. Don't let anger make you careless.””

Vanessa abruptly shook her head.

“That's enough.””

Marcus didn't look at her.

“Don't let her turn you against me,” Vanessa said.

“You know how grief can distort things. Renee wasn't herself at the end.””

Marcus's face tightened.

“You keep talking about my wife as if you knew her better than I did.””

“I knew things you didn't!””

“Then say them.””

Vanessa pressed both hands against her temples.

“I can't explain all of this here!””

“Why? Because two hundred people might hear the truth?””

“Because you don't know what happened!””

Marcus stood so quickly that the chair scraped across the floor.

“Then tell me!””

Vanessa recoiled.

For one second, he thought she might finally speak.

Instead, she looked toward the reception hall and shouted, “Someone get my mother!””

No one answered.

Andre had already stepped into the hallway to call security.

Marcus returned his attention to the recording.

Renee's voice had become quieter.

“One more thing. If Vanessa tells you I came to her for help, don't believe her. If she tells you I asked her to take care of Lily, don't believe her. And if she says she was with me the night everything changed…”

The recording stopped.

A small loading symbol spun across the cracked screen.

Marcus tapped the file.

Nothing happened.

He tried again.

The phone displayed a message: *AUDIO PLAYBACK ERROR. FILE DAMAGED.*

“No,” he whispered.

He pressed the screen again, then again.

“Come on, Renee. Please.””

Lily slipped away from Andre and hurried back to him.

“Daddy?””

Marcus knelt and held her hands.

“It's okay, baby.””

But the words felt hollow.

He looked at Vanessa.

“Were you with my wife the night she died?””

Vanessa's face crumpled.

“Marcus, I—”

“Were you?””

She glanced toward the doorway, where two security guards had appeared beside Andre.

Then she looked at Lily.

And the expression on her face changed from fear to something colder.

“You want the truth?”” Vanessa asked.

Marcus stood.

“Yes.””

Vanessa reached into the small hidden pocket of her wedding gown and pulled out a folded piece of paper.

“I didn't come into your life by accident,” she said.

She unfolded the paper with trembling fingers.

At the top was a date Marcus recognized immediately: the night Renee died.

Beneath it was a handwritten name.

*VANESSA COLE.*

May you like

My Wife Stole My Daughter’s Future to Give Her Sons Everything

The receipt in my hand was worth twenty thousand dollars. But the piece of paper my ten-year-old daughter had pulled from the tra...

The Secret My Wife Left Behind

The police officer didn't look at me when he said my wife's death might not have been an accident. He looked at Vanessa. And the...

The Billionaire's Daughter Was Slapped in Her Own Hotel—And the Manager...

The woman who slapped me had no idea whose baby I was holding. And the hotel manager who ordered me out had no idea that the buil...

And under her name, in Renee's unmistakable handwriting, were six words that made Marcus's heart slam against his ribs.

*If I die, ask Vanessa why.*